Christa Pike: The Brutal Murder of Colleen Slemmer, 30 Years on Death Row, and the Execution That Did Not Kill Her
There are some true-crime stories where you reach the ending and realize the ending has somehow become almost as disturbing and complicated as the crime that started it all.
The story of Christa Gail Pike is now one of them.
For more than 30 years, Pike was known primarily as the young Tennessee woman sentenced to death for the horrifying 1995 torture and murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer.
Pike was only 18 when the crime occurred.
She would become one of the youngest women in modern American history to receive a death sentence.
For decades, her case bounced through appeals, post-conviction proceedings, arguments over mental illness, childhood abuse, rehabilitation, the constitutionality of executing someone for a crime committed at 18, and ultimately a desperate fight for clemency.
Then came September 30, 2026.
Tennessee intended for that to be the final chapter.
It wasn't.
Christa Pike was strapped to a gurney inside Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville. Witnesses were assembled. Colleen Slemmer's mother had traveled to Tennessee after waiting more than three decades to see the sentence carried out.
The lethal drugs were administered.
Then Pike kept breathing.
She moved.
She spoke.
She complained that her arm hurt.
Witnesses heard sounds described as snoring and choking.
A second round of the execution drug was administered.
She still didn't die.
Eventually, an ambulance arrived.
Instead of leaving Riverbend in a hearse, Christa Pike left alive and was transported to a hospital.
Days later, she remained unconscious and on a ventilator.
And suddenly a murder case that began in a secluded area of Knoxville in January 1995 had become the center of an entirely new national conversation about punishment, justice, mental illness, victims' rights and whether the government can humanely carry out the ultimate punishment it imposes.
But before we get into what happened inside that execution chamber, we need to go all the way back.
Because this story didn't begin with Christa Pike.
It began with a 19-year-old girl named Colleen Slemmer.
Before She Became "The Victim," Colleen Slemmer Had a Life
One of the ugliest things about true crime is how easily the person who was murdered can disappear from their own story.
Their killer becomes famous.
Books are written about the killer.
Documentaries analyze the killer.
People study the killer's childhood, relationships, psychology, prison behavior and final meals.
Meanwhile, the person whose life was actually taken becomes a photograph and a paragraph.
Colleen Slemmer deserves better than that.
Colleen was 19 years old and originally from Florida. Her mother, May Martinez, has spent decades trying to make sure people understand there was an actual young woman behind the name attached to this case.
Colleen loved computers. Her mother has described her wearing a "Computer Geek" shirt and said she could take a computer apart and put it back together. Her grandfather encouraged her interest in technology and suggested she pursue computer training.
She also had a compassionate side.
Her mother has recalled Colleen volunteering with children with disabilities, helping children who used wheelchairs and giving up part of her own lunchtime to assist them. She volunteered at Special Olympics competitions and helped paint her school.
She roller-skated.
She laughed.
She went shrimping with her stepfather.
She had plans.
And like millions of teenagers and young adults, she was trying to figure out what came next.
That journey eventually brought her to the Job Corps program in Knoxville, Tennessee.
Job Corps was designed to provide young people with education and vocational training.
It was there that Colleen met Christa Pike.
And it was there that her life collided with a group of teenagers in a way her family could never have imagined.
Who Was Christa Pike?
Christa Pike was also a teenager trying to navigate a troubled life.
She entered Job Corps and studied nursing.
But her attorneys would later paint a devastating picture of the childhood that came before it.
During decades of litigation, Pike's defense presented evidence and arguments concerning childhood neglect, physical abuse, sexual abuse, mental illness and psychological instability. Her attorneys have argued that significant mitigating evidence about her upbringing and mental health was not adequately presented during the penalty phase of her original trial.
Those facts would eventually become central to the fight over whether she should be executed.
They do not excuse what happened to Colleen.
And that distinction matters.
Understanding why somebody became violent is not the same thing as saying their violence was acceptable.
Two things can exist in the same story.
A person can have experienced terrible things.
And that person can later do something terrible to somebody else.
Pike's life became intertwined with another Job Corps student named Tadaryl Shipp.
Shipp was 17.
The two became romantically involved.
And according to the prosecution's case, Pike became convinced that Colleen Slemmer was interested in Shipp.
Jealousy grew.
Resentment grew.
And eventually, according to court records, Pike decided Colleen needed to pay.
January 12, 1995
This is where the story becomes extremely difficult.
On January 12, 1995, Pike, Shipp, Colleen and another Job Corps student, Shadolla Peterson, left the Job Corps facility.
Colleen apparently believed there was going to be some kind of reconciliation.
Instead, the group went toward a secluded wooded area near the University of Tennessee agricultural campus.
According to court records, what followed lasted approximately 30 to 45 minutes.
Colleen was attacked.
She was beaten.
She was cut repeatedly.
She tried to escape.
She suffered defensive injuries.
The Tennessee Supreme Court's description of the evidence is horrific.
The medical examiner found so many slash and stab wounds that cataloguing every injury individually became impractical. Some of the injuries were superficial. Others were devastating.
A pentagram was carved into Colleen's chest.
Her throat was cut multiple times.
She suffered catastrophic blunt-force trauma to her head after being struck with a large piece of asphalt or rock.
The medical examiner ultimately determined that the blunt-force injuries to her head caused her death.
But there was something else about the crime that would make the case infamous.
A piece of Colleen's skull was taken from the scene.
According to testimony later presented at trial, Pike carried it with her.
Let that sink in.
This wasn't simply a fight that unexpectedly became fatal.
The evidence presented to the jury described prolonged violence against a young woman who was alive for much of what was being done to her.
And then came Pike's behavior afterward.
"That's Blood"
According to the Tennessee Supreme Court's account of testimony from Pike's acquaintances, Pike didn't immediately behave like someone overwhelmed with horror at what she had done.
Quite the opposite.
A friend testified that Pike talked about the murder while smiling, dancing and singing.
The following morning, Pike allegedly still had the piece of Colleen's skull.
During class, another student testified that Pike pointed to brown stains on her shoes and essentially explained that they weren't mud.
They were blood.
She then reportedly showed the student the piece of bone and described what had been done to Colleen.
Meanwhile, Colleen was missing.
On January 13, 1995, an employee with the University of Tennessee grounds department discovered her body near the agricultural campus greenhouses.
She had to be identified using dental records.
Her family had lost a daughter.
And within a remarkably short period of time, investigators had a trail leading directly toward Christa Pike and the people who had been with Colleen the previous night.
The Investigation and Confession
Pike eventually gave investigators a detailed statement.
Evidence also connected her directly to the crime.
The prosecution's case was overwhelming.
This wasn't a case built around one questionable witness or a single piece of circumstantial evidence.
There was Pike's own account.
There were statements she allegedly made to fellow students.
There was physical evidence.
There was testimony concerning the piece of Colleen's skull.
And there was the crime scene itself.
Pike was charged with first-degree murder.
Tadaryl Shipp was also prosecuted for his participation.
Shadolla Peterson cooperated with prosecutors and received a different outcome.
But one of the issues that would follow this case for decades was the dramatically different punishment Pike and Shipp ultimately received.
Pike received death.
Shipp received life imprisonment with the possibility of parole.
And that disparity would later become part of the larger debate surrounding Pike's execution.
Christa Pike Is Sentenced to Death
In 1996, a Tennessee jury convicted Christa Pike of first-degree murder.
The jury then had another decision to make.
Should this teenager spend the rest of her life in prison?
Or should Tennessee kill her?
The jury chose death.
Pike entered Tennessee's prison system and eventually became the only woman on the state's death row.
The Tennessee Supreme Court reviewed her conviction and sentence and affirmed them in 1998, finding that the evidence supported the jury's decision and that her death sentence was not disproportionate under Tennessee law.
But Pike's legal story was nowhere near finished.
It would continue for decades.
Prison Did Not Immediately Mean the Violence Was Over
One argument made on Pike's behalf in recent years has been that she matured dramatically during her decades in prison.
But her early years behind bars were hardly uneventful.
In 2001, Pike attacked fellow prisoner Patricia Jones.
She was later convicted of attempted first-degree murder for that assault and received an additional prison sentence. Tennessee records note that conviction as part of Pike's history while incarcerated.
That incident complicated any simple narrative that Pike entered prison and immediately transformed.
Whatever rehabilitation occurred appears to have taken years.
And eventually, her attorneys argued, something did change.
The Christa Pike Her Attorneys Said Emerged Decades Later
As Pike moved through her 30s and 40s, her defense team began presenting a different picture of the woman living on Tennessee's death row.
Her attorneys said Pike was eventually properly diagnosed and treated for serious mental-health conditions.
They argued that she suffered from bipolar disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder and that treatment had helped stabilize extreme mood swings.
They described her as remorseful.
They said she mentored other incarcerated women.
They said the impulsive, unstable 18-year-old responsible for Colleen's murder was not psychologically identical to the 50-year-old woman Tennessee planned to execute.
That became one of the fundamental questions surrounding her case:
How much should change matter?
If someone commits an atrocious murder at 18 and spends three decades becoming a substantially different person, does that matter when deciding whether the state should execute them at 50?
Some people say absolutely.
Others say absolutely not.
Because Colleen Slemmer never received those 30 years.
She never got the opportunity to mature.
She never reached 30.
Or 40.
Or 50.
September 20, 2026, would have been Colleen's 51st birthday.
Instead, her mother spent that birthday preparing to travel to Tennessee to watch the woman convicted of murdering her daughter be executed.
That is the brutal symmetry at the center of this entire case.
The Fight to Save Pike's Life
As Pike's execution approached, her attorneys mounted an aggressive effort to stop it.
They raised arguments concerning her age at the time of the crime, her mental health, her history of childhood trauma and abuse, her rehabilitation and the adequacy of the legal representation she received during her original trial.
Her attorneys argued that the jury that sentenced her to death never received a complete picture of the severe abuse and trauma she experienced as a child.
That issue even surfaced during the final U.S. Supreme Court fight.
On September 30, the day of the scheduled execution, a federal appeals court temporarily stayed Pike's execution while legal issues were considered.
But the United States Supreme Court vacated that stay.
Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented.
Sotomayor specifically referenced Pike's claim that her trial attorney failed to adequately present mitigating evidence concerning severe sexual abuse she experienced as a minor.
The execution could proceed.
And Tennessee was ready.
Or at least Tennessee believed it was.
September 30, 2026
Christa Pike was 50 years old.
Had the execution proceeded normally, she would have become the first woman executed by Tennessee in more than two centuries.
The state planned to kill her using pentobarbital.
Pentobarbital is a powerful barbiturate. In an execution, a sufficiently large dose is intended to produce deep unconsciousness, suppress breathing and ultimately cause death.
But there was already a significant warning hanging over Pike's execution.
Her attorneys had told the state that Pike had a medical history that could make intravenous access difficult.
According to later court filings from her attorneys, Pike had a blood condition and a history of medical professionals having difficulty finding usable veins and successfully placing IV lines.
Those warnings would become extremely important several hours later.
The Witnesses Enter
At approximately 6:41 p.m., witnesses were brought into the witness area at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution.
Then they waited.
And waited.
The curtain separating them from the execution chamber remained closed.
Journalists who had witnessed previous Tennessee executions later said the delay was unusual.
And while the curtain was closed, witnesses reported hearing sounds.
Crying.
Whimpering.
Groaning.
They could not see what was happening.
Pike's attorneys later alleged in court filings that the execution team used at least seven needles while attempting to establish IV access.
According to those filings, Pike even attempted to help the team identify a possible access site.
Her lawyers said one needle was bent at approximately a 90-degree angle when it was removed.
Remember: the witnesses couldn't see most of this.
The curtain was closed.
That secrecy would become one of the biggest controversies after the execution failed.
7:26 P.M. — The Curtain Opens
Finally, at approximately 7:26 p.m., the curtain opened.
Christa Pike was visible on the execution gurney.
She was restrained.
An IV line had been placed.
Her spiritual adviser stood near her.
Pike was permitted to give a final statement.
And what she said was unusual considering what everyone in that room believed was about to happen.
She spoke about love.
She said she intended to leave the world with love even for people who hated her.
She said she was at peace.
She said she was ready to be free.
And then she said:
"This is a happy day."
Her spiritual adviser remained near her head.
They sang together.
Witnesses couldn't make out every word, although "I love you" could reportedly be heard repeatedly.
Her spiritual adviser stroked her forehead.
The state began the process intended to end Christa Pike's life.
Then things started going wrong.
"My Arm Feels Like It's About to Burst Open"
At approximately 7:34 p.m., Pike complained about her arm.
According to witnesses, she said:
"My arm feels like it's about to burst open."
That sentence is now one of the most important pieces of the entire execution investigation.
Because pentobarbital is supposed to travel through a properly placed IV into the bloodstream.
Pike's attorneys and a medical expert retained by the defense now believe at least some of the drug may instead have infiltrated the tissue surrounding her veins.
That phenomenon is sometimes called infiltration or extravasation.
And pentobarbital is highly alkaline and can damage tissue.
Later, when Pike reached the hospital, her attorneys said both arms were swollen, burned and blistered.
Back inside the execution chamber, however, the procedure continued.
Pike reportedly told officials that one area was throbbing.
She asked whether what she was experiencing was supposed to happen.
Then witnesses noticed her breathing change.
7:37 P.M.
Pike began taking large, deep breaths.
Witnesses described seeing her body move with the force of those breaths.
She was still conscious enough to move.
Still responsive enough to react.
Still alive.
At approximately 7:39 p.m., she lifted her head and looked toward the IV.
Her feet continued moving beneath the sheet.
One witness later described her kicking frequently enough that the sheet covering her shifted.
Then, at approximately 7:41 p.m., something unusual happened.
A small rock or paperweight-like object was placed on a ledge visible to witnesses.
Reporters familiar with Tennessee executions said the placement appeared to correspond with a stage in the state's execution protocol.
Normally, by this stage of an execution, witnesses would expect the prisoner to be deeply unconscious.
Pike wasn't.
Witnesses could still see movement in her jaw.
She continued making sounds.
At one point she opened her mouth widely, which one witness compared to a large yawn.
Five minutes later, the curtain closed.
7:46 P.M. — The Curtain Comes Down
This is where the story gets even stranger.
At approximately 7:46 p.m., prison officials closed the curtain.
Witnesses could no longer see Christa Pike.
Her spiritual adviser left the execution chamber.
For several minutes, whatever happened to Pike happened outside public view.
Then, at approximately 7:49 p.m., the curtain reopened.
Pike was still alive.
Her spiritual adviser returned.
And witnesses began hearing a sound that would continue for an extraordinary amount of time.
Snoring.
Or at least something that sounded like snoring.
Pike appeared to be losing consciousness, but she continued breathing loudly.
Then came more movement.
At approximately 7:54 p.m., according to media witnesses, Pike grunted, lifted her head and opened her mouth.
Around two minutes later, one reporter described Pike's head and legs rising so that her body briefly formed a V-shape on the gurney.
This was not what witnesses expected to see during a lethal injection.
And Tennessee's protocol contained another step.
If the first round of pentobarbital failed to kill the condemned prisoner, another round could be administered.
So Tennessee tried again.
The Second Dose
A second round of pentobarbital was administered.
The small rock or marker was reportedly placed on the ledge again shortly after 8 p.m.
And Christa Pike continued breathing.
Witnesses reported that she continued making loud snoring-like sounds.
Her head and neck continued to move.
Her lips reportedly quivered.
At times the breathing sounded to witnesses almost like choking.
Then, around 8:05 p.m., the curtain closed again.
This time, it stayed closed.
But the microphone apparently remained active.
Which meant the witnesses could still hear her.
They just couldn't see her.
Behind the Curtain
For roughly the next 40 to 50 minutes, witnesses sat in a room listening to Christa Pike breathe.
Rhythmic breathing.
Snoring-like sounds.
Doors opening.
Doors closing.
Movement somewhere beyond the curtain.
But they couldn't see what officials were doing.
One media witness, Steven Hale of the Nashville Banner, later emphasized how much of the critical event occurred with the curtain closed.
Pike was clearly still alive.
Yet the people legally assembled to witness the execution had no visual access to what was happening to her.
Pike's attorney Randy Spivey later said that at approximately 8:22 p.m., he demanded access to a telephone so he could contact the rest of Pike's legal team.
According to Spivey, he demanded that the execution be stopped and that Pike receive emergency medical treatment.
Minutes passed.
Pike continued breathing.
Finally, around 8:50 p.m., according to her attorney, he received confirmation that an ambulance was coming.
At approximately 8:53 p.m., witnesses were told to leave.
There was no announcement that Christa Pike had died.
Because she hadn't.
An Ambulance Arrives at Death Row
Around 9:14 p.m., emergency vehicles arrived at the prison.
Christa Pike was removed from Riverbend Maximum Security Institution alive.
Think about the sheer strangeness of that sentence.
The State of Tennessee had obtained a death warrant.
The courts had allowed the execution to proceed.
Pike had been restrained on the execution gurney.
She had given what she believed were her final words.
The state had administered two rounds of the drug intended to kill her.
Witnesses had waited for a declaration of death.
Instead, paramedics were now trying to save her life.
She was transported to a Nashville-area hospital.
Tennessee's execution had failed.
Tennessee Initially Said It Followed the Protocol
Late that night, the Tennessee Department of Correction issued a brief statement.
The department said it had followed every step of Tennessee's lawful execution protocol.
It said the lethal-injection chemical had previously been effective.
And crucially, the department said the protocol did not permit additional procedures beyond what had already been attempted.
It confirmed that Pike had been transported to an off-site medical facility.
That statement immediately raised a mountain of questions.
If the protocol had been followed correctly, why was Pike alive?
Were the IV lines actually inside functioning veins?
How much pentobarbital entered her bloodstream?
How much entered surrounding tissue?
Why had she complained that her arm felt as though it were going to burst?
What happened during the long periods when witnesses could hear Pike but couldn't see her?
And perhaps most importantly:
Why did it take so long to transition from an execution attempt to emergency medical care?
The Injuries
Once Pike reached the hospital, the seriousness of the situation became clearer.
According to her attorneys, both of Pike's arms were swollen, burned and blistered.
She was unconscious.
She was intubated.
She required a ventilator to breathe.
Doctors began trying to stabilize her and clear the massive amount of pentobarbital from her system.
Her lawyers sought a court order requiring Tennessee officials to preserve evidence connected to the failed execution.
That included material that could potentially establish what drugs were used, how the IVs were placed, what happened behind the curtain and why the execution failed.
A medical expert working with Pike's defense suggested that the injuries were consistent with pentobarbital leaking outside the vein and entering surrounding tissue.
That could potentially explain something that otherwise seems contradictory:
How could the state administer enough pentobarbital to supposedly kill someone twice—and still fail to kill them?
If substantial amounts of the drug weren't actually reaching the bloodstream as intended, the answer becomes less mysterious.
But it also becomes more disturbing.
Because the drug may have been damaging tissue instead.
As of October 5, 2026, Pike's attorney said she had not regained consciousness and remained hospitalized on a ventilator. Her long-term neurological and physical prognosis remained unclear.
And Then Tennessee's Corrections Commissioner Resigned
The fallout did not stop at the prison gates.
Tennessee Department of Correction Commissioner Frank Strada announced his resignation as scrutiny intensified.
Governor Bill Lee halted executions for the remainder of 2026 and ordered an independent review.
Former U.S. Attorney Ed Stanton was selected to lead that review.
The investigation is expected to examine what happened during Pike's execution attempt and Tennessee's broader execution procedures.
And that matters because Pike's execution did not happen in a vacuum.
Tennessee's lethal-injection system had already faced years of controversy.
The state previously paused executions after problems were uncovered involving the testing of execution drugs.
An independent review found failures in the state's execution-drug procedures, including problems concerning required testing.
Executions eventually resumed.
Now Tennessee has another crisis on its hands.
And this one unfolded with witnesses sitting just feet away.
But Colleen's Mother Was Sitting There Too
This is the part that cannot get swallowed by the debate over Christa Pike.
May Martinez was there.
Colleen's mother had waited more than 30 years.
She traveled from Florida to Tennessee.
She brought a photograph of her daughter.
She had said before the execution that she wanted to hold Colleen's picture up.
Not because she believed anything could bring her daughter back.
But because after decades of headlines centered around Christa Pike, May wanted Colleen in that room too.
She wanted her daughter remembered.
Instead, she watched another nightmare unfold.
The first dose didn't kill Pike.
The second dose didn't kill Pike.
She watched Pike moving.
She watched her trying to lift herself.
And eventually Pike was transported to a hospital.
Martinez later summed up her reaction in words far simpler than all of the legal arguments surrounding the case:
"This isn't justice for Colleen."
And I think that sentence deserves to sit right in the middle of this entire conversation.
Because whatever your position on capital punishment, May Martinez waited three decades for the justice system to fulfill the sentence it told her family would be carried out.
Instead, she left with another traumatic memory.
Now Comes a Legal Question Almost Nobody Expected
What happens if Christa Pike survives?
That is no longer hypothetical.
She survived the execution itself.
The question is whether she survives the medical consequences.
And if she does, Tennessee faces extraordinary legal and constitutional questions.
Can the state try to execute her again?
Pike's attorneys say the answer should be no.
They are urging Governor Bill Lee to commute her death sentence to life imprisonment.
Their argument is not simply that the first attempt failed.
They contend that Pike has already endured a prolonged, painful and potentially permanently disabling execution attempt and that subjecting her to another would raise profound constitutional concerns.
There could also be questions about Pike's medical condition and competency if she eventually awakens with significant brain or neurological damage.
As of October 5, her lawyer Stephen Ferrell said it was still unclear whether she would regain consciousness.
He has urged Tennessee to "take death off the table."
So a case that spent three decades asking whether Tennessee should execute Christa Pike may now become a case about whether Tennessee legally can try again.
There Are No Easy Heroes in This Story
This is where people tend to retreat into camps.
One side says:
Look at what Christa Pike did to Colleen Slemmer.
And they're right.
It was horrifying.
Another side says:
Look at what the state apparently did to Christa Pike in that execution chamber.
And they're right to demand answers about that too.
Those ideas are not mutually exclusive.
Condemning the torture and murder of Colleen Slemmer does not require pretending that anything done to her killer is automatically acceptable.
And questioning whether the government tortured a prisoner during a failed execution does not require minimizing what that prisoner did.
We should be capable of holding more than one moral thought at a time.
Colleen Slemmer did not deserve what happened to her.
Her mother did not deserve three decades of grief.
Christa Pike was responsible for an extraordinarily brutal crime.
Pike was also 18 when she committed it.
Evidence concerning her severe childhood trauma and mental illness became central to later appeals.
She spent approximately 30 years under a death sentence.
And on September 30, 2026, the government attempted to kill her.
Twice.
It failed.
Now doctors are trying to keep alive the same woman the state was legally trying to kill.
If that sentence sounds absurd, that's because the situation itself is extraordinary.
The Victim Cannot Become a Footnote
There is one more thing we need to talk about.
The internet is fascinated by Christa Pike.
Her age.
Her mugshots.
Her childhood.
Her mental illness.
Her behavior after the murder.
Her life on death row.
Her final statement.
Her execution.
Her survival.
Now her hospital condition.
And somewhere beneath all of that attention is Colleen.
That's exactly what her mother has been trying to prevent.
Colleen was not born "Christa Pike's victim."
She was someone's daughter.
She loved computers.
She roller-skated.
She helped children with disabilities.
She had a family that loved her.
She was 19.
She was supposed to have decades ahead of her.
And on January 12, 1995, those decades were stolen.
Christa Pike got to turn 20.
Colleen never turned 20.
That matters.
But What Happened in That Execution Chamber Matters Too
The government holds a unique power.
It can imprison you.
And in states with capital punishment, under narrowly defined circumstances and after extensive judicial proceedings, it can kill you.
That power carries an enormous responsibility.
An execution isn't supposed to become an experiment where officials keep administering drugs while witnesses listen to someone breathing behind a curtain and attorneys scramble to get emergency medical care.
If Tennessee's investigation determines that pentobarbital infiltrated Pike's tissue because IV lines were improperly placed or failed, that deserves scrutiny.
If warnings about Pike's difficult venous access were ignored, that deserves scrutiny.
If she suffered chemical injuries while restrained and unable to escape, that deserves scrutiny.
If officials waited unnecessarily before providing emergency medical care, that deserves scrutiny.
Not because Christa Pike was innocent.
She wasn't.
But constitutional protections do not disappear because someone committed a horrific crime.
That's precisely when those protections are tested.
More Than 31 Years After Colleen Walked Into Those Woods, This Still Isn't Over
January 12, 1995.
A 19-year-old girl followed three other teenagers toward a secluded area in Knoxville.
She never came back.
The murder eventually sent an 18-year-old Christa Pike to death row.
For approximately three decades, Tennessee courts, federal courts, lawyers, governors, activists, victims' advocates and Colleen's family argued over what justice should ultimately look like.
On September 30, 2026, Tennessee believed it had reached the answer.
Christa Pike would die.
Witnesses gathered.
The Supreme Court cleared the way.
The IVs went in.
Pike said her final words.
The drugs began flowing.
Then she said her arm hurt.
She kept breathing.
The curtain closed.
It opened.
She was still alive.
More drugs were administered.
She kept breathing.
The curtain closed again.
Witnesses could still hear her.
Eventually, an ambulance pulled up to a prison where everyone had expected a hearse.
And Christa Pike left Riverbend alive.
As of October 5, she remains unconscious and on a ventilator, according to her attorney. Nobody publicly knows whether she will wake up, what condition she may be in if she does, or whether Tennessee will ever be legally permitted to attempt her execution again.
The state has paused executions.
Its corrections commissioner has resigned.
An independent investigation is underway.
Pike's lawyers want her death sentence commuted.
And May Martinez is still without her daughter.
That last fact is the one thing no court ruling, execution, commutation or investigation can ever change.
Colleen Slemmer would be 51 years old today.
Instead, her mother has spent more than three decades saying her name.
So yes, the world should investigate what happened to Christa Pike inside Tennessee's execution chamber.
We should ask whether the state followed its own rules.
We should ask whether she was tortured.
We should ask whether officials ignored medical warnings.
We should ask why witnesses were left listening to her breathe behind a closed curtain.
We should ask whether another execution attempt could ever be constitutional.
But while we're asking all of those questions, let's make sure we remember the name that started this case in the first place.
Colleen Slemmer.
Nineteen years old.
Daughter.
Volunteer.
Computer lover.
A young woman planning a future she never got to live.
Because whatever happens next to Christa Pike, that is the part of this story that should never disappear.
Editor's Note — October 5, 2026 This story is developing. Christa Pike survived Tennessee's September 30 execution attempt and remains hospitalized. Her medical condition, the state's independent investigation and potential litigation over whether Tennessee may attempt another execution could materially change. This article should be updated as verified information becomes available.
Sources & further reading The factual history of the murder and original trial is documented in the Tennessee Supreme Court's 1998 opinion in State v. Pike. Read State v. Pike The Tennessee Department of Correction confirmed after the failed execution that Pike had been transported to an off-site medical facility while maintaining that officials followed the state's execution protocol. Tennessee Department of Correction statement Recent accounts of the execution are based on eyewitness reporting and subsequent statements and court filings from Pike's attorneys.
Comments