Holiday Spending Is Forecast to Top $1 Trillion. Why Do So Many Consumers Still Feel Financially Strained?
The United States is heading into a holiday season that retailers expect to be historically strong, even as millions of consumers say the economy feels increasingly difficult to navigate.
The National Retail Federation projects that retail sales during November and December will increase 4.2% from 2025 and reach approximately $1.013 trillion. If the forecast is realized, it would mark another record holiday season.
At the same time, the University of Michigan’s final October 2026 consumer sentiment index registered 48.0, almost unchanged from September but 10.4% below its October 2025 level. The survey’s current economic conditions index fell to 46.7, and respondents continued to cite affordability, interest rates and purchasing power as major concerns.
The two figures appear contradictory only if spending is treated as a synonym for financial comfort. It is not.
Retail Spending Can Rise While Households Feel Worse
National retail sales measure the amount of money moving through consumer transactions. They do not measure whether those purchases were comfortable, whether they were financed with debt or whether families had to reduce spending elsewhere to afford them.
Holiday consumption is also influenced by forces that do not disappear when confidence falls. Families continue to exchange gifts. Parents still buy for children. People travel to see relatives. Religious and cultural traditions continue. Consumers may be anxious about the economy and still prioritize holiday spending.
NRF’s own consumer research reflects that tension. Fifty-six percent of holiday shoppers said the state of the economy would affect their plans, while 43% said they intended to begin shopping before November. Shopping early can be a strategy for finding discounts, but it can also spread purchases across multiple pay periods.
The Dollar Total Does Not Tell Us How Much People Are Actually Getting
One reason record spending can coexist with financial strain is inflation. A higher dollar total does not necessarily mean consumers are buying significantly more goods. It may simply cost more to purchase the same basket of products.
That distinction becomes especially important when comparing today’s holiday totals with figures from several years ago. Household budgets are also being shaped by housing, insurance, utilities, groceries, transportation and borrowing costs—expenses that compete directly with discretionary holiday spending.
A household can therefore spend more on Christmas than it did last year while feeling less financially secure.
Consumer Sentiment Is Capturing the Emotional Side of the Economy
The University of Michigan survey is useful because it measures perceptions rather than transactions. In October, respondents reported worsening conditions for major purchases, with the survey attributing much of the decline to higher interest rates and affordability concerns.
Year-ahead inflation expectations rose to 4.7% in the October survey, while long-run expectations increased to 3.5%. Those expectations do not predict inflation with certainty, but they help explain why consumers may approach the holidays defensively even when they continue to spend.
People make financial decisions based not only on what prices are today, but on what they believe may happen next.
Holiday Spending Is Also Emotional Spending
Economics alone cannot fully explain holiday behavior. Gift giving carries emotional and social expectations. Parents may sacrifice personal purchases to preserve traditions for children. Grandparents may stretch budgets to buy for multiple grandchildren. Families may spend on travel because holiday gatherings are among the few times everyone is in the same place.
Retailers understand those pressures. Holiday advertising is built around urgency, scarcity, nostalgia and the fear of missing an opportunity. Limited-time sales, countdowns and promotional financing can make purchases feel more manageable in the moment.
That does not make consumers irrational. It does mean holiday spending often reflects values, relationships and expectations as much as disposable income.
Buy Now, Pay Later Can Blur the Real Cost
Installment products have become a prominent part of online shopping because they divide a large purchase into smaller payments. For some households, that can be a useful cash-flow tool. For others, multiple overlapping plans can make it difficult to understand how much future income has already been committed.
The most important question is not whether buy-now-pay-later services are inherently good or bad. It is whether the payments still fit the household budget after rent, groceries, utilities and January bills are included.
Record Sales Do Not Mean Financial Stress Is Over
The 2026 holiday season may ultimately deliver both strong retail numbers and significant household anxiety. Those outcomes are not mutually exclusive.
A national total of $1.013 trillion says something important about the scale of consumer activity. A sentiment reading of 48.0 says something equally important about how consumers feel while participating in that activity.
For families, the more practical measure of a successful holiday may be whet
her the spending creates a financial problem after the decorations come down.
A More Useful Holiday Budget Standard
Rather than starting with a gift list, households may benefit from starting with a total number they can spend without carrying the season into January as new financial stress.
That can mean setting a household cap, reducing adult gift exchanges, planning travel expenses in advance, comparing total costs rather than monthly payment amounts, and distinguishing traditions that genuinely matter from purchases made only because they are expected.
The national economy may generate a trillion-dollar holiday season. Individual families still have to decide what a sustainable holiday looks like inside their own budget.
Comments