Roc Nation Casino Rejected

The $5.4 billion proposal to bring a casino to the heart of Times Square has been officially rejected. In a dramatic 4–2 vote, the community advisory committee delivered a decisive "no" to the joint bid from SL Green, Caesars Entertainment, and Jay-Z's Roc Nation. The decision, which took place in a conference room just around the corner from the proposed site at 1515 Broadway, effectively kills the project before it could even be considered by the state's Gaming Commission.

The Battle for Broadway's Soul

The vote marks the culmination of a months-long clash between the casino's powerful backers and a united front of Broadway theater owners, producers, and workers. While the developers argued the casino would be a much-needed shot in the arm for Times Square, promising thousands of jobs, increased tourism, and a new entertainment complex, opponents saw it as a direct threat to the very essence of the neighborhood.

The "No Times Square Casino Coalition," which included the Broadway League and multiple theatrical unions, argued that a gambling hall would fundamentally change the character of the theater district. They feared it would siphon off audiences and revenue from shows, worsen already-congested streets, and disrupt the unique ecosystem of artists and small businesses that defines the area. As Broadway League President Jason Laks put it, "A casino can go anywhere, but Broadway only lives here."

A Divided Committee

The six-member Community Advisory Committee, composed of local residents appointed by elected officials, was tasked with weighing these competing visions. The final vote reflected a deep divide. The four "no" votes were cast by representatives appointed by state senator Liz Krueger, assembly member Tony Simone, Manhattan borough president Mark Levine, and council member Erik Bottcher. Their decision was a clear response to the overwhelming opposition voiced by local residents and the Broadway community during public hearings.

Conversely, the two "yes" votes came from the appointees of Mayor Eric Adams and Governor Kathy Hochul, both of whom had supported the project. The developers reacted with fury after the vote. SL Green CEO Marc Holliday reportedly confronted committee members, calling their decision a "despicable display of cowardice" and a missed opportunity for the city.

What's Next for the Casino Race?

The rejection of the Times Square bid is a significant moment in the race for three downstate New York casino licenses. With another Manhattan proposal also being voted down on the same day, the path is now clearer for other bids in the outer boroughs, such as those in Queens and the Bronx. For Times Square, it's a return to the drawing board. For Broadway, it's a victory and a confirmation that the magic of the theater district remains a powerful force.